A lot of people took issue with this weapon, in defense it was indeed literally the worst weapon if you just use the banished sword and put on Elden Ring Runes the same Ash of War, so by comparison this weapon really wasn't worth acknowledging at the time. However, we have had some improvements since then, great swords in two hand which this weapon is perfect for have been improved, its Ash of War was specifically improved as well, the motion speed of that and the range of the blade itself was buffed so the speed was massive for its viability and use but the range was really nice. 

Further, the weapon will deal damage too, further on the Ash of War the hit of the weapon will also deal damage, meaning if you use it like close up melee distance you'll get an extra burst as the sword hits as well as the holy sort of Ash of War. Finally the attack power of the buff itself was improved and it lasts way longer, so clearly this web weapon is improved, as well as it being an undeniable very cool looking sword with a pretty fairly unique Musa. The problem is again, the banished sword exists it's the same move set, you can put the same Ash of War on it, but this weapon is in a better place and a good place at that.

Siluria's Tree is also newly made it to the tier list, a coolest spear that some of The Crucible Knights use, it has had some improvements itself. Specifically the Ash of War Siluria's Woe has had its motion speed massively improved which means you can actually land the thing in PvP against those that's trying to avoid it, so some relevance improvements there. 

But it deals more damage in PVE, it comes with its own hyper armor so you can trade with the Ash of War now. And the weapon has damage detection as well, so you can use it at melee range, hit with a weapon and the Ash of War, and get an even bigger burst. You can tap the Ash of War and it'll do a quick slam down in a holy explosion at close range, or if you hold it, it'll charge up and shoot out this beam of light at a very respectable range, that beam can now penetrate enemies meaning you can get multiple hits or AOE possibilities. So that's a massive improvement for this weapon in the Ash of War specifically in best site to buy elden ring items various ways which is really all it needed, the weapon was always solid as a great spear with a good moveset but now it's a really good pick.